Differences between Contract of Service and Contract for Service

In today's dynamic employment landscape, grasping the disparities between a contract of service and a contract for service is paramount for both employers and workers alike. These distinctions dictate crucial elements such as tax obligations, liability, and the nature of the employment relationship. For employers, understanding these nuances is vital for the proper classification of workers, ensuring compliance with labor laws, and mitigating legal risks.

What is a Contract of Service?

A Contract of Service is a crucial agreement between an employer and an employee, offering security and protection to both parties involved. For employees, this contract provides clarity and assurance regarding their role within a professional setting, delineating their obligations and expectations. Employers, on the other hand, benefit from the assurance that these obligations will be fulfilled and have legal recourse in case of contract breaches. Key components of a Contract of Service include Key Employment Terms (KETs) and essential clauses specifying working hours and job scope.

The Employment Act encompasses various categories of employees, including:

• Full-time workers: Work an average of 40 hours per week and receive benefits such as healthcare and vacation days.
• Part-time employees: Work fewer than 40 hours weekly and usually do not receive full benefits.
• Temporary employees: Hired for short durations based on company needs
• Contract employees: Employees who engaged for predetermined periods or projects, often known as freelance workers.

Payment methods for these employees vary, including hourly, daily, monthly, or piece-rated compensation.

The Employment Act may encompass a range of benefits, including sick leave, annual leave, maternity leave, incentives, bonuses, relocation assistance, healthcare benefits, retirement fund contributions, childcare benefits, and transportation reimbursements. Recognizing the significance of fostering a supportive work environment, these benefits not only enhance productivity and employee retention rates but also positively impact the company's bottom line.

What is a Contract for Service?

In a Contract For Service, the relationship between the parties is more akin to that of a client and a contractor rather than an employer and an employee. This means the person performing the service is usually self-employed or an independent worker, like a freelancer.

While Contracts For Service offer flexibility for both parties, it's essential to note that they don't come with the protections and benefits provided by the Employment Act. This lack of statutory benefits means individuals operating under such contracts are responsible for managing their own leave, insurance, and other aspects typically covered by employment laws. It's a trade-off for the flexibility and autonomy that freelancers often seek in their work arrangements.

Differences between Contract of Service and Contract for Service

Key Points When Drafting Each Contract

Contract of Service:

• Employment: Specifies the individual's appointment as an employee and their designated position within the company.
• Place of Work: Indicates the primary location where the employee is expected to carry out their duties and whether relocation may occur within the organization.
• Duties and Obligations: Clearly outlines the responsibilities and tasks assigned to the employee, along with expectations for performance.
• Representation and Warranties: Affirms that all provided documents are accurate and that the employee is legally capable of entering into the agreement.
• Remuneration and Benefits: Details the total compensation package, including base salary, bonuses, and other financial perks.
• Probation Period: Specifies if a probationary period is applicable and its duration.
• Intellectual Property Rights: Establishes ownership rights over intellectual property, unless otherwise agreed upon.
• Non-compete and Non-solicit: Prohibits the employee from engaging in similar services with third parties, including competitors, during and after employment.

Contract For Service:

• Retention of the Service Provider: Clarifies that the service provider is not an employee but rather an independent contractor or freelancer.
• Scope of Work: Defines the specific tasks and performance expectations of the service provider.
• Consideration: States the agreed-upon payment amount for the services rendered.
• Ownership: Specifies that any work created during the contract period belongs exclusively to the company.
• Assignability: Prohibits the service provider from assigning the contract to another party without prior written consent from the company.
• Confidentiality: Requires the service provider to maintain confidentiality regarding any information obtained during the contract period.
• Indemnification: Obligates the service provider to compensate the company for any third-party breach claims.
• Termination: Grants the company the right to terminate the agreement if the service provider fails to meet agreed-upon deadlines or deliverables.

Read More on Ajobthing : 

• Finding the Perfect Fit: 5 Personality Tests for Hiring Process
• 6 Key Hiring Trends Shaping Malaysia
• Optimizing Your Workforce: Hiring Part-Time Employees in Malaysia
• 7 Simple Ways to Improve Employee Performance with KPIs
• Understanding Form E: A Comprehensive Guide to E-Filing Submission

AJOBTHING: Your All-in-One Hiring Solution

With AJOBTHING, you get everything you need for hiring in one place. Our HR libraries are packed with helpful resources, and our recruiter advice is personalized to your hiring needs. No more juggling multiple platforms. With AJOBTHING, everything you need is in one convenient place. Join us today and see how we can make hiring simpler and more effective for you.

Urgently seeking candidates to hire?
Look no further! AJobThing offers an effective hiring solution with our instant job ad feature. Hire in just 72 hours! Try Now!