In recent years, the conversation surrounding mental health has gained considerable traction. As society becomes more aware of the significance of mental health, it is natural that this awareness extends to the workplace. The debate surrounding the necessity of employers asking candidates about their mental state has gained significant attention in the realm of HR. Let's delve into this complex issue and explore both sides of the argument.

The Importance of Mental Health

Prior to everything else, it's critical to understand the importance of mental wellness. Just as physical illness affects a person's ability to perform tasks, so does mental health. Stress, depression and anxiety disorders, as well as other mental health conditions can impact a person's work performance, job satisfaction, and overall quality of life. Acknowledging this reality is an important step towards creating a more supportive and empathetic work environment.

Read more: Prioritize Mental Health In Workplace

Should Employers Ask a Candidate About Their Mental State?

Malaysia lacks specific laws regulating the questions employers can ask about a candidate's mental health during the hiring process. Malaysia has implemented laws like the Employment Act 1955 and the Occupational Safety and Health Act 1994 to safeguard employees' rights and health. These laws indirectly address the issue of mental health by emphasizing the importance of providing a safe and healthy work environment.

The Malaysian government, through the Ministry of Human Resources, is actively promoting mental health in the workplace through various initiatives and guidelines. Nevertheless, these initiatives primarily focus on supporting employees rather than governing pre-employment inquiries.

Related: How to Approach an Employee About Their Mental Health

Why Some Employers Ask About Mental Health

1. Employee Well-being: Employers who inquire about a candidate's mental state may genuinely value their employees' well-being. They want to create an inclusive workplace where employees feel comfortable discussing their mental health openly.

2. Performance Assessment: Understanding a candidate's mental state can help employers assess whether they can handle the demands of the job. This approach may lead to better job-person fit and lower turnover rates.

3. Accommodations: Employers can make necessary accommodations for people with mental health needs, similar to those for physical disabilities. This fosters a more inclusive work environment.

4. Company Culture: Some companies are proactive about promoting a culture of mental health awareness. It is possible to perceive asking about mental health as a method to support this culture and promote candid talks.

Why Some Oppose Asking About Mental Health

1. Stigmatization: One of the main concerns about asking candidates about their mental health is the potential for stigmatization. Candidates may fear discrimination or bias if they disclose their mental health issues.

2. Privacy Invasion: Some argue that mental health is a private matter and should not be a factor in hiring decisions. Personal privacy is a fundamental right that employers should respect.

3. Legal Implications: In some jurisdictions, asking about an applicant's mental health can be legally problematic. Employers may inadvertently open themselves up to discrimination lawsuits.

4. Lack of Expertise: Employers may not have the expertise to assess a candidate's mental state accurately as they are not mental health professionals. Misjudgments or assumptions can lead to unfair decisions.

How to Create a Safe Space For Your Employees

Employers can take several steps to promote mental health without prying into a candidate's personal life:

1. Create a Supportive Culture: Focus on fostering a culture of mental health awareness within the organization. This encourages employees to seek help when needed.

2. Offer Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): Offer employees access to Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs), which can be a valuable resource for those dealing with mental health concerns.

3. Educate Managers: Train managers to recognize signs of mental health issues and provide appropriate support.

4. Normalize Mental Health Conversations: The text suggests promoting open dialogue about mental health during interviews, without directly asking candidates about their mental state.

Conclusion

The question of whether employers should ask candidates about their mental state is a complex one. Employers must prioritize the mental well-being of their workforce, despite valid reasons for and against this. Creating a supportive environment and offering resources for employees should be the primary focus. The ultimate objective is to strike a balance between addressing mental health issues and upholding an individual's right to privacy.

Try Instant Job Ad today and guarantee to hire your ideal staff within 72 hours!

Don't wait any longer to tap into A Job Thing's vast talent pool of 5 million active candidates. With our Instant Job Ad feature, you can kickstart the hiring process immediately and welcome right talent on board in no time. Get started now and secure your top talents within 72 hours!